Cafe Amalfi Restaurant

Pizza Restaurants in Sarasota, Florida

4.2 (476)

Category	Pizza Restaurants · Italian restaurant, Pasta shop, Pizza delivery, Pizza Takeout
Address	1880 Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34231
Area	Sarasota, Florida
Phone	(941) 922-7069
Google rating	4.2 (476)

Hours

Monday	Closed
Tuesday	12–8 PM

About Cafe Amalfi Restaurant

Best local pizza near Siesta Key and South Sarasota. Cafe Amalfi Restaurant in Sarasota traditional pasta dishes to our succulent seafood and perfectly Every dish at Cafe Amalfi is a testament to authentic Italian craftsmanship located in Sarasota right next to south Siesta Key in Sarasota Fl. Whether you're looking for a hearty lunch, slice of pizza or cappuccino to cap off your meal. Owner John personally greets and cooks for every every guest.

Cafe Amalfi Restaurant is one of the pizza restaurants listed in Sarasota, Florida. The business is registered at 1880 Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34231; use this page to check its hours, phone number and Google rating before you make the trip. Google also lists it under italian restaurant, pasta shop, pizza delivery, which is worth knowing if you are comparing several options in the area.

In Sarasota, the busiest hours are Friday and Saturday evenings and any night with a big game, when quoted delivery times can stretch past an hour; ordering before 5 p.m. or picking up yourself avoids the wait. Delivery radiuses are small, often two to five miles, and a minimum order plus a delivery fee is normal, with a tip of a few dollars for the driver on top. Lunch specials such as two slices and a drink, or a personal pie, are the cheapest way to eat at most shops across Florida on weekdays. Toppings are priced per item and half-and-half pies are usually free to request. Gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese are increasingly common but often cost a few dollars extra, and cross-contact in a shared oven is standard unless the shop says otherwise.

Hours are published for 1 day a week. Typical hours are 12–8 PM. It is closed on Monday. Hours in the United States do change around federal holidays and long weekends, so a quick call before a special trip is sensible. You can reach Cafe Amalfi Restaurant at (941) 922-7069; calling is usually the quickest way to ask about availability, prices or directions. More information is available on its website, cafeamalfi.com.

With 4.2 out of 5 on Google from 476 reviews, it sits in the middle of the range for pizza restaurants in Sarasota. Recent reviews are the best guide.

Sarasota is in Florida, in the Southeast, where summers are long, hot and humid, winters are mild, and afternoon thunderstorms and the hurricane season from June to November can change plans at short notice. Traffic in Sarasota peaks on weekday mornings and afternoons, so allow extra time then. Addresses read from the street number up to the city, state abbreviation and five-digit ZIP code; the map link on this page shows the exact spot.

Looking for alternatives? Browse all pizza restaurants in Sarasota or explore other categories in the area from the links below. If you own or manage Cafe Amalfi Restaurant, you can claim this listing to correct details, add photos and a description, and receive a verified badge. Everyone else can help by leaving an honest review on Google after a visit.

Is this your business? Claim this listing to update details, add photos and get a verified badge; every verified claim gives $1 to charity. Want more customers? Feature it at the top of pizza restaurants in Sarasota.

Latest Google reviews

The 5 most recent reviews shown on Google Maps. Reviews belong to their authors; read all of them on Google.

Chai Voris 3 months ago

Best Italian food I’ve had in FOREVER!!! Everything is homemade! Best meatballs, garlic knots, gnocchi, Alfredo sauce and pizza! Crust was PERFECT! Wish I lived here. It would be my regular restaurant. AND it was very affordable.

Shawn Beus 3 months ago

The pesto pistachio pasta with whole pitaschios was excellent. Good Italian bread and the cheese by the slice was decent. The issue was there is no tap water, and for people who don't like soda or the waste of bottled water, the server/owner and a guest or friend of his complained that we weren't paying for their best marked up prices, and the landlord was expansive and we just drank from our own water bottles. They spoke quite loudly, either ignorantly, or trying to diss on us on purpose. Either way, it was very irritating to us and we couldn't wait to leave. But the pesto/pistachio was $24 and didn't come with any salad so we bought the most expensive dish and still ordered a nicely priced side salad. That said, the owner/serve was overall fine besides that. It is a small place with lots of Italian decor that felt straight out of NYC.

Dominique Boscia a year ago

So I went off of most reviews and thought, I should give these guys a chance. Absolutely not worth the money. its edible, definitely not a Sicilian pie, what i would consider a half order of calamari, veal parm cutlet was good but awfully small. I dont know if you are trying to save money or your cook just doesn't know what he is doing. For the folks that dont like a sweet sauce , this place is not for you

Kimberly Hartman 2 years ago

A very small quaint place, only 6 tables in the entire place. In previous reviews the owner got a lot of negative reviews but he was very friendly with us. Yes he does the majority of the cooking and serving, but was very efficient , he had one other server on that night as well, but again it’s a small place. The food is homemade authentic but everything has a sweetness to the sauces, that is not my favorite and why I gave it a 3. If you like that style of sauce then you will love it.

Beep; Boop Beep! 5 years ago

We do family pizza night every Saturday and thought we had been to every place in town. We were surprised to learn of Cafe Amalfi and on a tip from a stranger we gave it a try. We dropped in on a Saturday at about 8p and there were only 2 other tables seated so it was quiet. The service was really good (pretty sure he was the owner). The food came out super quick, almost surprising fast, yet it was perfectly cooked. The pizza crust was thin, but not too thin, it was just thick enough to give nice stability but not so dough’ie that you felt stuffed after one piece. The crust flavor was outstanding. The fresh mushrooms were the best we’ve ever had on a pie, hearty slices so they didn’t cook down to mush. French fries were good too, steak fries. It’s not a complaint, but a comment, the French Fry appetizer portion is kinda small. We ended up with like 15 to 18 fries per order so keep that in mind based on the size of your group and passion to crush fries. All in all, great find and we’ll certainly visit again.

All reviews on Google ↗

Frequently asked questions

Where is Cafe Amalfi Restaurant located?

Cafe Amalfi Restaurant is at 1880 Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34231, in Sarasota, Florida. Use the “Open in Google Maps” button on this page for directions.

What kind of business is Cafe Amalfi Restaurant?

Cafe Amalfi Restaurant is listed as a pizza restaurant and is also tagged on Google as italian restaurant, pasta shop, pizza delivery.

What are the hours of Cafe Amalfi Restaurant?

Published hours are Monday: Closed; Tuesday: 12–8 PM. It is closed on Monday. Hours can change on holidays, so call before a special trip.

What is the phone number of Cafe Amalfi Restaurant?

You can call Cafe Amalfi Restaurant at (941) 922-7069.

How is Cafe Amalfi Restaurant rated on Google?

Cafe Amalfi Restaurant has a Google rating of 4.2 out of 5 from 476 reviews.

Does Cafe Amalfi Restaurant have a website?

Yes, the website of Cafe Amalfi Restaurant is cafeamalfi.com (linked on this page).

Are there other pizza restaurants near Cafe Amalfi Restaurant?

Yes. Sarasota also has Capo Pazzo Pizzeria + Kitchen, Shaner's Pizza - Gulf Gate Sarasota, Atmosphere Pizza among others; see the full list of pizza restaurants in Sarasota at the bottom of this page.